I pulled out 12 different pedals to compare and maybe sell off some of the excess pedals I have. I plugged them all in and dialed them in the way I thought they sounded best with the amp. Played the same riff and licks with each pedal. 
Mojave Peacemaker head, THD Hotplate, Mojave 4x12 w/G12h30's, SM-57, Vintage API Mic Pre, Suhr Standard.
0:00 - 00:32 Peacemaker straight, no pedals
0:34 - 1:06 Fulltone OCD
1:08 - 1:40 Maxon OD9
1:42 - 2:26 MI Audio Blues Pro
2:28 - 3:04 Keeley Modded Boss SD-1 (older one, no extra switch)
3:07 - 3:43 Keeley Modded TS-9
3:45 - 4:18 Digitech Bad Monkey
4:20 - 4:53 DOD YJM308
4:56 - 5:28 MXR 6 Band
5:30 - 6:04 Fulltone Full Drive II
6:06 - 6:39 Boss SD-1 Stock (Made in Japan)
6:41 - 7:14 Original vintage Ibanez TS-9
7:16 - 7:52 Maxon OD808
http://www.dinosaurrockguitar.com/listeningroom/Boost_Pedal_Shootout.mp3